Tourism, the New Colonialism?
We’ve been coming to the island (SXM) for over twenty-five years now. As any long-time or term visitor, we’ve seen the growth, overdevelopment on the Dutch side, land grabs on the French side, devastation from various hurricanes, resilience and comebacks.
When we were newbies, our kids were all under the age of ten. Being more of the “accidental tourist” we only knew the island was French and Dutch. Before that first timeshare trade, we had never even heard of Sint Maarten/Saint Martin. The Flamingo Resort was where that trade took us. We loved it so much we bought in. We were young and clueless. That being said, we see how the island and its people are generous, helpful and patient with less informed visitors.
Since then our children have grown and we’ve graduated to home ownership on the Dutch side, along with a vehicle. Point A to B has been a process that began with love at first sight. Included in that were many lessons along the way. We’ve observed how guests have enjoyed and played while the island has accommodated both the needs and wants of its visitors. Restaurant menus are great example of this. While there are so many countries represented in cuisine the majority reflect the palettes of Americans (I’m American, so I am focusing on them, but it seems as though Canadians fall into the same choices). Pizza, hamburgers, steak, lobster (many not liking the Caribbean version), quesadillas and chicken fingers prevail at so many venues. (Ironic that quesadillas are Mexican fare.) Does anyone even know what Dutch cuisine is? I’ve seen a few places offer a small selection as appetizers along with the usual expectations. Has anyone tried any of them? They’re really good. Even the French have Americanized their menus. Some tourists enjoy bragging about where they’ve eaten the best steak and lobster.
The bad behavior of a few tourists have ruined things for everyone else. On the French side, it is customary rhum shot at the end of a meal. Before Irma some restaurants and beach bars would bring a bottle of MaDouDou and often leave it on the table. We watched a group on the beach drink the whole bottle and then take it with them when they left. It had been hand painted. Most recently, seventeen year-old boys from Canada and America downed a few buckets of beer on the beach. They got into a “my country is better than yours”, in drunken slurs — pissing match.
So when complaints surface on social media, I have lost my patience and not commented in a politically correct manner. The latest one was about the traffic. One commenter basically said they were taking their marbles and not playing here — on the island anymore. My response was to not “let their a$$ hit the door.” Another commenter jumped in and told me I was rude. Now, I do find that ironic coming from an American. The sentiment there lately toward complainers is to “love it or leave it”, yet don’t like that when visiting another country. Many of these tourist complaints drip with the sound of entitlement. “My vacation” — it’s not your country or culture. It isn’t always about the tourist. There are problems inhabitants already have.
This kind of reminds me of the first explorers. Let’s review what they did: claimed the islands for their particular country, used genocide via either physically or culturally, they transported,sold, bought, and used slaves to build their fortunes, fought with other explorers or countries for domination and outright ownership. I’m sure someone with more knowledge can add to and enhance this list. Racism, too, still exists. While many are respectful to islanders, some references we’ve heard make us and some of you —cringe. Respect goes a long way here as in the rest of the Caribbean.
Unfortunately, some Americans have such an inflated view of themselves. Expectations are demands in disguise. They, and other tourists, have forgotten their status here is “guest”. SXM is one of the most hospitable and accommodating island in the Caribbean, yet it is never enough. Those claiming to love the island, should love it all — the good, the bad, the ugly. The giant sand box is not a litter box!
Yes, the island has its problems. Some of them are growing pains and some are greed. Our take away from SXM is that it is a microcosm. The smaller land mass can only take so much stress. Pollution from their energy source, vehicles (yes, ie: traffic), cruise ships, yachts, cigarette butts, chewing gum, styrofoam take out containers, single use items all add up to disrupt the beautiful ecosystem. Locals and tourists could do better. That should be the takeaway to take home. Be polite, show respect for the people and the island itself, do your part and seriously… refrain from complaining when possible. Instead ask yourself what you can do to make SXM a great place to visit for the next generation.